31
Random Chat / Re: Healthcare Reform?
« on: March 23, 2010, 09:16:57 PM »EDIT: lol at the idea that letting people die/getting 5-figure health costs is just fine because government are just "public servants" so free health care is not a right
Wait when did I say letting people die/getting 5-figure health costs is alright? "Free" health care cannot be a right because a right is a freedom of action; health care is a service that can be bought and traded, not an action that can be carried out by an individual by their own volition. As I said, you could argue that the government may have a duty to provide such goods, commodities, and services, but they are not natural rights because they contradict what rights are.
I don't think the government should run health care, or act as a public insurance company because they give themselves a de jure monopoly. To say that the government wouldn't act as evil as an evil insurance company that would be granted a monopoly, and made it so people had to purchase from them or be fined, or would only exist to force competition, would be like saying that an evil insurance company who would be granted a monopoly, with the government making it so people had to purchase from them or be fined, and were exempt from taxes, regulations, ect, would turn out to be the greatest insurance company of all time who would never look out for their own self-interests.
And in regard to the government trying to force competition: it can't. It can't force growth, competition, innovation, or anything that the free market system is great at. Any such is artificial, akin to stapling a pair of bird's wings to a dog and claiming they've created a new species.
BUT in regard to your point, any person who is in need of medical services would ideally be taken care of by charity. Ideally, charity hospitals and not for profit organizations would take care of these people; believe it or not, people's benevolence is more effective and of a higher quality than the "charity" of the government.
PS. The only thing wrong with the insurance companies is that they exist in a country whose economic system is not that of laissez-faire capitalism, but of crony capitalism.